Abstract
Objectives: We describe the eligibility criteria, recruitment, and enrollment of the children and families in the Utah Children’s Project. We describe the measurement components of the UCP, including questionnaire instruments, geographically based exposure assessment, direct environmental assessment (including home air quality), DNA extraction, RNA banking, microbiome biosamples, and blood and urine banking.
Methods: In 2014, the University of Utah School of Medicine, Woman and Child Institute, launched the Utah Children’s Project, a child and family cohort study, to understand how genes and the environmental exposures around the time of conception, pregnancy, infancy, and early childhood act to influence health, growth, and development of children. The UCP enrolled participants from six prior cohorts that enrolled mothers and sometimes fathers in the preconception or prenatal period. We invited parents, children, and up to one sibling to enroll in the UCP for long-term follow-up of health of the children and their parents. In 2016, the UCP joined the Environmental Influences on Child Health Outcomes Program (ECHO) Consortium of the National Institutes of Health.
Results: We describe the participation of UCP in ECHO, which has added many additional instruments and measures. We elucidate our successful efforts with remote data collection, which were accelerated by the COVID-19 pandemic.
Conclusions: Longitudinal data collection, for our cohort of children and families, supports research at both a national and local level. The successful methodologies employed in the UCP may be useful to other researchers planning to establish long-term prospective cohort studies.
Implications: This data collection enables national and local researchers to capture trends in the environment that may be transformative to children’s health.
Introduction
Environmental exposures around the time of conception and during pregnancy, infancy, and early childhood can have lasting effects on the health and well-being of children. The Developmental Origin of Health and Disease theory suggests that environmental exposures during these critical times may also play a role in the development of diseases in adulthood.1,2 Environmental exposures and behaviors may change a person’s epigenetics which can impact future generations.3
Over the last 50 years, there has been a sharp increase in major childhood health problems, including prematurity, obesity, asthma, and autism.4 The University of Utah School of Medicine launched the Utah Children’s Project (UCP) in 2014 to understand how genes interact with our surroundings to influence child health, growth, and development. This child and family cohort was built upon prior NIH-funded cohorts, such as National Children’s Study and Home Observation of Periconceptional Exposures studies, that enrolled pregnant mothers (and sometimes fathers) in prenatal or preconception period. In 2016, the UCP joined the Environmental Influences on Child Outcomes Program (ECHO) Consortium of the National Institutes of Health.5 As of this writing, there are 46 ECHO sites across the United States, including more than 50,000 children and mothers from diverse populations, funded to examine the impact of early environmental exposures on child health and development.5,6 The ECHO Program seeks to understand how environmental exposures from preconception through early childhood influence child health and development, with the ultimate goal of identifying strategies to reduce disease risk and promote optimal health and well-being. By joining this nationwide collaborative research initiative, UCP secured funding to continue its study and gained the opportunity to contribute meaningful data and scientific insights to advance understanding of child health trajectories.
The purpose of this article is to provide a detailed description of the Utah Children’s Project, including enrollment and study procedures. We describe the participation of UCP in the ECHO consortium and described possible opportunities for future use of UCP data.
Methods
Utah Children’s Project
There were two enrollment stages of the UCP. In the first enrollment stage, participants were recruited to join the Utah Children’s Project between 2014 and 2019 if they had participated in one of the following NIH-funded prenatal and/or preconception cohorts: National Children’s Study – Salt Lake County Initial Vanguard Site (NCS – SLC; Utah PI: Ed Clark; enrolled 2009-2012),7 National Children’s Study – Cache County (NCS – Cache; Utah PI: Ed Clark; enrolled 2010-2012),8 Nulliparous Pregnancy Outcomes Study: Monitoring Mothers-to-be (nuMoM2b; Utah PI: Robert Silver; enrolled 2010-2013),9 Home Observation of Periconceptional Exposures (HOPE; PI: Christy Porucznik; enrolled 2011-2015),10 Baby Affect and Behavior Study (BABY; PI: Elisabeth Conradt; enrolled 2016-2018),11 Time to Pregnancy in Couples of Proven Fecundity (TTP; PI: Joseph Stanford; enrolled 2003-2005.12 The key selection criteria for each of the source cohorts and their inclusion and exclusion criteria are described in Table 1, and details of their aims and recruitment are given in the Supplemental File 1. Participants were recruited to UCP by telephone, email, and mailers. Original consents into the UCP occurred between June 12, 2014, and September 27, 2019. The second enrollment stage occurred after UCP joined ECHO. During this stage, participants were enrolled in 2022-2023 through the Preconception to Perinatal Outcomes (PPO) component, described further below (Table 1). By enrolling through PPO, UCP increased the number of participants recruited in the preconception period. Participants who enrolled in PPO were offered enrollment in ECHO as the babies were born.

UCP Eligibility
The original eligibility criteria for enrolling into UCP were:
- Index child (or children in the case of twins) from one of the preconception/prenatal cohorts described in this paper.
- Index child less than 18 years of age at enrollment
- Residence in Utah at the time of enrollment
- Child and at least one biological parent willing to participate and provide blood (preferred) or saliva for DNA to be analyzed in the study. The other biological parent is encouraged to participate, but this is not required
- One full biologic sibling (older or younger, but less than 18 years; could be two in the case of twins) may also participate, but this is not required
Preconception to Perinatal Outcomes component
In addition to the original UCP participants described above, the UCP has also enrolled additional pregnant persons and couples trying to conceive, with subsequent enrollment of the child and at least one parent (but no sibling) into the study. These participants are also described further in Table 1 and the Supplemental File 1.
UCP Initial Visit. The enrollment visit included the index child, at least one biological parent, and often also an additional biological parent and biological full sibling. Written informed consent was obtained from all adults (18 years and older); verbal assent from children 7 to 17 years, and parental written informed consent for all participants less than 18 years. For most children, questionnaires were completed by a parent. All participating family members completed medical histories, which were reviewed and verified by a clinician, questionnaires about the pregnancy for each child, a physical exam, and biospecimen collection, including venous blood, blood spots on FTA cards, and saliva. Medical histories of the index pregnancies were reviewed and verified by a clinician. Biospecimens were collected to enable the analysis of biological markers that reflect environmental exposures and health outcomes over time. These samples are essential for understanding the mechanisms by which early-life exposures influence child development and long-term health. Participants also underwent anthropometric measures, including height, weight, waist, hip, blood pressure, and heart rate. For some very young children, venous blood draw, blood pressure measurement, and hip measurement were waived based on parental preference. These visits were conducted at the University of Utah, Center for Clinical and Translational Science, in Salt Lake City, and Utah State University, the Center for Persons with Disabilities, Logan, Utah.
UCP Follow-up Visit with Microbiome Assessment and Dental Exam
The initial UCP follow-up visit was designed to be completed around one year from the enrollment visit. Only mothers and participating children were invited to complete the visits (fathers were not included). Medical history addenda were completed for each participant, with a particular focus on antibiotic history, and dental history. Biological samples collected from the mother included nasal and vaginal swabs, and urine. The children provided nasal and rectal swabs, and urine. In addition, both mothers and children, provided saliva if it had not been collected at the initial visit. Microbiome sample collection questionnaires were distributed to each participant. Anthropometrics were performed including height, weight, waist, hip, blood pressure, and heart rate. Dental examinations with full mouth high resolution photographs were performed by a dental hygienist for children four years and older.
UCP Home Air Quality Monitoring
One of the key environmental exposures with high health impact in Salt Lake County and Cache County is air pollution. For precision measurement of air quality for participants in UCP, Utah investigators employed locally-developed low-cost air quality monitors, deployed in participant homes. This focused on the home deployment of these home monitors, and their acceptability, utility, efficacy, and ability to estimate environmental exposures inside and outside the homes of UCP participants.13-16 Through 2019, fifty families were recruited per a convenience sample from our existing cohort. Due to Covid pandemic restrictions, contact and home visits to maintain these monitors were severely restricted during 2020-2021. Retrieval of the sensors and their data, from the homes, finalized in 2023.
Environmental Influences and Child Health Outcomes (ECHO)
Beginning in late 2016, the ECHO Consortium brings together existing cohorts of child research participants with various physical, chemical, social, behavioral, and biological exposures assessed preconceptionally, prenatally, or up to 5 years of age. Children are followed to age 21. The standardized data collected by ECHO sites focus on the following outcomes: pre, peri, and postnatal outcomes; neurodevelopment; upper and/or lower airways; obesity and related conditions; and positive health. All ECHO sites collect standardized demographics, typical early health and development, genetic influences on child health and development, environmental factors, and person-reported outcomes (PROs). Instruments and data collection forms are implemented in a centralized REDCap database and can be completed by study personnel during a visit or virtual visit, or often, by the participant or parent directly. Some data forms are collected once; others are collected more than once at different life stages.
UCP Implementation of ECHO
UCP applied and was selected to join the ECHO Consortium. This secured funding for the continuation of the study and created a mechanism to contribute UCP data to a broader scientific community working to address critical longitudinal research questions. From July 12, 2019, to April 26, 2022, existing UCP participants consented again to join the ECHO-wide protocol. Participants could choose between two levels of consent. Level 1 consent permits de-identified data and biospecimens to be shared and used only within the ECHO consortium for approved studies. Level 2 consent includes these permissions but also allows sharing with qualified researchers outside of ECHO, including through NIH-designated repositories, for broader scientific use.
Upon joining the ECHO Consortium, UCP modified existing data collection and added additional data collection to match the ECHO-wide consortium protocol. The existing data collection process was modified to support the development of the ECHO-wide Cohort data platform, which incorporates essential data elements from all ECHO Cohort Awardees and their respective cohorts, as well as recommended data elements from selected subsets of Cohort Awards. Key changes to the data collection approach include contacting participants annually around the time of their child(ren)’s birthday(s), replacing most clinic visits with online surveys, conducting in-person clinic visits for children every five years, and implementing a special one-time visit with a parent. The total number of data collection forms from the ECHO-wide protocol for Level 2 participants engaged by UCP participants is over 120 forms. These are detailed in Supplemental File 2. Yearly visits in UCP cover all the elements of the ECHO-wide protocol for each childhood life stage. Biospecimens (blood, urine, hair, toenails) are collected at visits around ages 5, 10, and 15 years. Primary deciduous teeth are collected between visits. We administer the ECHO-wide questionnaires to children and parents that cover a broad domain of exposures and health. The NIH Toolbox Cognition Battery, which assesses executive function, attention, episodic memory, language, processing speed, and working memory, is also administered.17 We retain the name, Utah Children’s Project for our local participants, all of whom are also part of the national ECHO dataset. The UCP and ECHO studies, which share the same study design, aim to investigate environmental exposures that influence child health and development, beginning in the preconception and prenatal periods and continuing through birth, infancy, early and middle childhood, and adolescence. After joining ECHO, we began collecting data required by ECHO-wide protocol, while also continuing to collect data specific to UCP interest. For example, in-home air quality monitoring was a unique component of the UCP study.Challenges and adaptations to COVID pandemic. With the advent of the COVID-19 pandemic, UCP discontinued all in-person study visits as of March 11, 2020. We began conducting virtual visits on April 8, 2020, which included continued remote administration of ECHO questionnaires and remote biospecimen collection, including hair, toenails, urine, saliva, and deciduous teeth. As of April 8, 2021, a nurse began phlebotomy visits at willing participants’ homes. As of May 26, 2022, we resumed clinic visits, including anthropometric and blood pressure measurements, NIH Toolbox Cognition Battery, and biospecimen collection, including hair, toenails, urine, and saliva or blood.
Results
Across all original source cohorts, 1492 families were invited to participate in UCP. From these 536 families enrolled, including 957 children, 535 mothers, and 322 fathers. Completing further enrollment into the initial ECHO protocol (level 1 ECHO consent), there were 514 families, 919 children, 513 mothers, and 222 fathers. Completing further enrollment into ECHO (level 2 ECHO consent), there were 490 families, 879 children, 489 mothers, and 89 fathers. Details for each stage of enrollment and reasons not enrolled at age stage are detailed in Figure 1. Among all families invited to be screened for participation in ECHO, the participation rate for Level 2 was 32.8% (490/1492). Among all families screened for eligibility and found to be eligible (n=559), the participation rate for Level 2 was 87.7% (490/559).

At the time of consent and assent into ECHO (Level 1 or 2), 29 children were in infancy (age 0 to 11 months 30 days), 423 were in early childhood (age 1 to 5 years 11 months 30 days), 399 were in middle childhood (age 6 to 11 years 11 months 30 days), and 71 were adolescence (age 12 to 20 years 11 months 30 days).
Demographic characteristics of participants in ECHO Level 2 are detailed in Table 2. At the time of consent and assent into ECHO Level 2, the mean age of all children was 9.7 years, of mothers 39.1 years, and of fathers 40.5 years. The participants were predominantly white and Non-Hispanic. Most parents of the children were married, and the mean household size was 5.2 persons. Nearly half (46%) of families had a household income greater than $100,000 yearly.

Many data collection components of UCP preceded the ECHO-wide protocol. These are detailed by number of participants completing each in Table 3. Although most were completed prior to receiving ECHO funding, many of these contributed data and specimens to ECHO. For example, extracted DNA was contributed to the ECHO biospecimen repository and included in ECHO analyses, as were nasal swabs, serum, and urine.

Other data collection components were completed as part of the ECHO-wide protocol. These are detailed in Table 4 by number of participants completing in each life stage, as of June 2022. As noted above, because of the COVID-2019 pandemic, there were fewer specimens collected during 2020-2022 by in-person visits, which reduced the amount of blood, blood spots, saliva, and urine collected below what was planned. Remote biospecimen collection allowed for higher levels of collection of hair, toenails, and deciduous teeth.

Discussion
We believe that the UCP and broader ECHO projects will lead to significant discoveries in the fields of medicine and public health, similar to the Framingham Heart Health Study, the Nurses’ Health Study, and other longitudinal cohort studies. The data collected will be studied by researchers worldwide to improve children’s health for decades to come.
Ninety-eight percent of children enrolled in UCP who were eligible to enroll in ECHO choose to enroll. We enrolled 919 children, 115% of the planned enrollment into the ECHO program, and 513 mothers and 222 fathers.
UCP specimen collection pre-dated our entry into the nationwide ECHO cohort. The genetic value of trios (child and both parents) and expanded families (2 siblings, both parents) may be of high value in future studies that draw from available ECHO specimens.
The nation-wide ECHO project was originally funded from 2016-2023. A second cycle of ECHO is currently underway since 2023, and is planned to continue to 2030, as described at echochildren.org. This will ensure the continuation and expansion of the value of ECHO for future generations.
Conclusions and Implications
Longitudinal data collection, for our cohort of children and families, supports ongoing research at both a national and local level. UCP and the entire ECHO consortium demonstrate the ability to recruit and retain participants from established cohorts to assess the impact of exposures from preconception, during pregnancy, and early childhood on child health and development. The ECHO-wide Cohort allows investigators to explore various research questions across the five ECHO outcome domains.18 This approach allows a wider community of scientists to address critical longitudinal research questions that no single cohort, or even a few, could answer alone.
Acknowledgements
We would like to acknowledge the visionary leadership of Ed Clark, which was essential to the founding of the Utah Children’s Project. We would like to acknowledge many individuals who have contributed to the UCP as investigators, study staff, graduate student research assistants, or consultants: Flory Nkoy, Nikki Mihalopoulos, Yue Zhang, Mark Innocenti, James VanDerslice, Rena D’Souza, Robert Schlaberg, Elisabeth Conradt, Deborah Bilder, Clint Mason, Sarang Yoon, James Winkler, Barbara Dixon, Ruston Barrows, Jacob Zimmerli, Chris Blatchford, Mihai Virtosu, Joemy Ramsay, Esther Chang, Jacob Anderson, Mary Kathryn Curcio, Chandler Cottam, Michelle Ngo, Mary Ruth Wiggins, Hafsa Zahid, Brooke Bushman, Tiffany Castro, Julien Froude, Josh Marchant, Maydeen Ogara, Tammy Mellon, Michelle Redfield, Yingjie Wei, Haojie Li, Ray Soto, Diane Morrill, Evan Heller, Hannah Nilsen, Catherine Schultz, Amanda Moloney-Johns, Suzanne Stradling, Michael Spigarelli, Jerry Anderson, Zelen Salmingo, Nadia Van Der Watt, Kathryn Szczotka, Volker Freimann, Jeff Yearly, Katherine Schwei, Caitlin Romney, Trent Henry, Litty Paul, Andrew Izatt, Julie Koldewyn, Nikki Rice, Alexis McNeil, Leslie Salamanca, Runcheng Fang, Colin Maguire, Juhee Peterson, Dabin Yeum, Jihye Park, Shinyoung (Mariana) Ju, Melissa Pringle, Josh Cameron, Regan Jackson, LaShai Jake, Lizette Larned, Ishita Singh, Kristina Gale, Joe Van Duren, Kathryn Andrus, Katelyn Lewis, Jennifer Ellen Mueller, Max Sidesinger, Melissa Hansen, Gary Thomson, Marissa Maddie.
We acknowledge the staff and resources of the University of Utah Center for Clinical and Translational Science, and the staff and resources of the Clinical Trials Office of the Department of Pediatrics, University of Utah.
Finally, we acknowledge the families and children who have participated in the UCP.
Funding
Initial funding for the Utah Children’s Project was provided by the Department of Pediatrics, University of Utah. Subsequently funded by grants from the National Institutes of Health, Office of the Director, ECHO Program, under grant numbers UG3OD023249 (PIs Stanford, Porucznik, Clark), and UH3OD023249 (PIs Stanford, Porucznik, Giardino).
References
1. Wadhwa PD, Buss C, Entringer S, Swanson, JM. Developmental origins of health and disease: brief history of the approach and current focus on epigenetic mechanisms. Semin Reprod Med. 2009;27:358-68.
2. Barker DJ. The origins of the developmental origins theory. J Intern Med. 2007;261:412-7
3. Fleming TP, Watkins AJ, Velazquez MA, et al. Origins of lifetime health around the time of conception: causes and consequences. Lancet. 2018;391:1842-52.
4. Trasande L, Landrigan PJ. The National Children’s Study: a critical national investment. Environ Health Perspect. 2004;112:A789-A90.
5. Knapp EA KA, Parker CB, et al. The environmental influences on child health outcomes (ECHO)-wide cohort. Am J Epidemiol. 2023;192:1249-63.
6. Environmetal influences on Child Health Outcomes. Observational studies (ECHO Cohort) 2025 [Available from: https://echochildren.org/echo-cohort/.
7. Landrigan PJ, Trasande L, Thorpe LE, et al. The National Children’s Study: a 21-year prospective study of 100,000 American children. Pediatrics. 2006;118:2173-86.
8. McGovern PM, Nachreiner NM, Holl JL, et al. The National Children’s Study: early recruitment outcomes using the direct outreach approach. Pediatrics. 2016;137:S231-S8.
9. Haas DM, Parker CB, Wing DA, et al. A description of the methods of the Nulliparous Pregnancy Outcomes Study: monitoring mothers-to-be (nuMoM2b). Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2015;212:539.e1-.e24.
10. Porucznik CA, Cox KJ, Schliep KC, Wilkins DG, Stanford JB. The Home Observation of Periconceptional Exposures (HOPE) study, a prospective cohort: aims, design, recruitment and compliance. Environmental Health. 2016;15.
11. Ostlund BD, Vlisides-Henry RD, Crowell SE, et al. Intergenerational transmission of emotion dysregulation: Part II. Developmental origins of newborn neurobehavior. Dev Psychopathol. 2019;3:833-46.
12. Stanford JB, Smith KR, Varner MW. Impact of instruction in the Creighton model fertilitycare system on time to pregnancy in couples of proven fecundity: results of a randomised trial. Paediatr Perinat Epidemiol. 2014;28:391-9.
13. Collingwood S, Zmoos J, Pahler L, Wong B, Sleeth D, Handy R. Investigating measurement variation of modified low-cost particle sensors. J Aerosol Sci. 2019;135:21-32.
14. Vercellino RJ, Sleeth, DK Handy RG, Min KT, Collingwood SC. Laboratory evaluation of a low-cost, real-time, aerosol multi-sensor. J Occup Environ Hyg. 2018;15:559.
15. Hegde S, Min KT, Moore J, Lundrigan P, Patwari N, Collingwood S, Balch A, Kelly KE. Aerosol and Air Quality Research. 2020;20:381-94.
16. Johnston JD, Magnusson BM, Eggett D, Mumford K, Collingwood SC, Bernhardt SA. Sensor drift and predicted calibration intervals of handheld temperature and relative humidity meters under residential field-use conditions. J Environ Health. 2014;77:22-8.
17. Gershon RC, Wagster MV, Hendrie HC, Fox NA, Cook KF, Nowinski CJ. NIH toolbox for assessment of neurological and behavioral function. Neurology. 2013;80(11):S2-S6.
18. Gillman MW, Cella D, Oken E. Environmental influences on Child Health Outcomes (ECHO)-wide cohort data collection protocol overview. 2017.
Citation
Porucznik CA, Chang EC, Myrer R, Ellsworth AD, Collingwood S, Lee H, Ferrell M, Johnson B, Giardino A, Palmer L, Edwards S, Rogers A, & Stanford JB. (2026). The Utah Children’s Project: Design, Enrollment and Measures for a Child and Family Cohort. Utah Women’s Health Review. doi: 10.26055/d-c6z6-128z





































